Sounds to me like your replaying a non-Dolby-d cassette but with Dolby active on the cassette deck, or possibly the wrong eq settings [eg metal selected for a non-metal tape].
I'd take all claims by all programs other than Audition about their being able to enhance the results of the transcription process with a vey large pinch of salt. Audition has very sophisticated controls for "cleaning up" your recordings - they do need to applied very sparingly after much trial and error. The very nature of cassette noise artifacts namely; hiss, wow & flutter, over saturation, means that they are impossible to remove without distorting the music itself.